Rachel Lindsay stopped by Jimmy Kimmel Live! last night, after the premiere of The Bachelorette. Keeping with tradition, Jimmy took it upon himself to predict Rachel’s final three choices, including, of course, her final pick. With the help of his wife and one of his producers, the host revealed who he believes Rachel chose, and why. Check out the clip below:

Video Credit: YouTube/Jimmy Kimmel Live

Jimmy said his predictions are usually correct, so we shall see! He did tease Rachel, though, adding, “I hope it works out. They never work out, you know that right?”

“Well, I would love to be the first. I would love to prove you wrong,” Rachel quipped.

Catch the next episode of The Bachelorette on Mondays at 7 p.m. on ABC.