When asking an actress who her best onscreen kiss was, you might expect it to be the actor she went on to marry, right? Well, not for Jennifer Lopez!

The 47-year-old beauty stopped by the Today show with Kathie Lee Gifford and Jenna Bush Hager, (temporarily filing in for Hoda Kotb) and opened up about her hottest professional lip-lock.

“It was Josh Lucas. It was called An Unfinished Life, with Robert Redford and Morgan Freeman.”

It must have been quite memorable, since that film came out more than 11 years ago! It appears it was mutual, too. In January of 2015, Josh gushed about Jennifer on Watch What Happens Live. He said, “She was phenomenal in many ways in that way. We have a phenomenal sex scene in a car that was so good [that] I guess it was cut out. They needed to get it a rating that was a little more PG. It was fantastic.”

Sorry, Ben!