Good news Bachelor nation! You may finally be able to put down your box of tissues: Amanda and Josh may be getting back together!

The overly-amorous pair from last season’s Bachelor In Paradise had quietly split in December, ending their engagement and leaving fans wonder what had gone wrong. But E!News tells us the two had a very cozy night together this past Sunday. According to a source, the two were “very affectionate” with each other, kissing and canoodling throughout dinner.

So is it back on? Josh spoke to ET yesterday during a Facebook live chat to update fans on the scenario. Of the possibility of reconciliation, he said, “There’s a possibility for anything.” He went on:

“You know, we’re trying to deal with stuff in a more private manner now, obviously, and we just kind of want people to respect that. Especially because it’s a tough situation with the kids, and we don’t want to kind of fully dive into anything, because we’re thinking about them as well. This is the first time I’ve seen her in a while. When I came out this week, I came for one of my friend’s events, and I did some other stuff while I was here, and we ran into each other and stuff. You know, we just had long conversations. They were conversations that needed to be had, and [we had] a great dinner. It was a good evening. We had a good time. Whenever we’re together, especially outside of the show and outside all the drama, it’s always been a good relationship. There were just so many outside forces and outside factors that got involved after we were together on the show, and it was unfortunate for a little bit.”

Looks like time will tell if they can make it work. We’ll keep you posted!