We’re starting to think that Fantastic Beasts’ star Eddie Redmayne is truly magical — for real. The actor recently appeared on The Tonight Show and did one hell of a magic trick for Jimmy Fallon. 

“I was embarrassingly into magic as a kid,” Eddie said, claiming that he would always have a magician at birthday parties. “At age 15, 18 I still had one. No one came to the parties, but I still had magicians.”

Then, he did a trick: “In this pocket here, I have a special something for you,” he said, handing Jimmy an envelope with his name written on it in real “Hogwartsean” writing. The rest you’re just going to have to see for yourself: