The latest episode of Cosmopolitan’s Pet Me Please, couple Gavin and Robbie are looking for their first pet.

While Gavin has his heart set on a dog, Robbie is eyeing a cat. Together, they visit The Humane Society of New York and the ASPCA to look at their options. And let’s say, this is getting me all the feels.

Just for the record. Which do you prefer: cats or dogs?