Matthew Perry stopped by Watch What Happens Live on Thursday night, and was put in the hot seat big time.

Though it was his first time meeting the Friends star, host Andy Cohen decided to “go deep” with Matthew with a round of “Plead the Fifth.”

Matthew was given a series of questions, only one of which he was allowed to exercise his rights and decline to answer. He used this pass on the very first question when he was asked to assign his female Friends co-stars to the words, “Marry, Shag, Kill.”

When asked if there was ever a Friends storyline that made him feel the show had jumped the shark, Matthew revealed:

“There was a storyline on ‘Friends’ where Chandler went to a male strip joint because he really liked the sandwiches. I called up and said, ‘Let’s not do this one.’”

Find out what the verdict was on that and hear the other question below:

Video Credit: YouTube/Watch What Happens Live with Andy Cohen